Trauma is subjective – your personal reaction to something. Just because you experience trauma from something does not mean someone else who was at the same event will experience trauma.
The argument has been over whether it is the event that should count most when looking at psychological trauma, or if it is a person’s response to an event that should define trauma.
Some researchers claim that there is an overdiagnosis of psychological trauma, claiming that it is too often confused with personal vulnerability.
Others would argue that saying some people are only traumatised due to ‘personal vulnerability’ is very limiting and unfair.
After all, who knows what other trauma the person in question has seen? Is it not possible that trauma can be cumulative? Would that mean the person is ‘too vulnerable’, or rather very strong? Is it ‘vulnerable’ to be born with a sensitive and responsive personality? Is trauma not the experience of the survivor, not the event itself?
A more recent definition diplomatically puts psychological trauma as the result of the interaction of the intensity of a traumatic event and an individual’s vulnerability.
Finally, and rather sadly, mental health is an industry. Official definitions of psychological conditions sometimes become less about helping those who require support, and more about determining who can receive medication, government assistance, and mental health insurance coverage.
A diagnosis that only emerged as late as 1980, it originally only applied to a stressor so horrible that, as the DSM stated, it was ‘generally outside the range of human experience’. It wasn’t until 1987 that the definition of PTSD was changed to include things like child sexual abuse or having a serious illness. Nowadays psychological trauma also includes witnessing violent events happening to others.
constantly being exposed to trauma (such as firemen and police are).
‘Delayed-onset PTSD’ is defined as having PTSD symptoms starting more than six months after the traumatic event. It is a diagnosis that is debated in psychological communities. Some disagree on its prevalence, and others disagree on if it even exists, especially in cases where there were no symptoms at all before the PTSD surfaces.
In some cases, where emotional shock doesn’t clear up after a reasonable amount of time, and other requirements are met, it can then become a diagnosis of PTSD.
Emerging forms of psychological trauma
Trauma is complex. Often we experience many traumas across our life, or come from a family replete with trauma. New ways of looking at trauma have been surfacing.
One of these is intergenerational trauma, also called ‘historical trauma’ or ‘transgenerational trauma’. This is where one generation experiences such severe trauma that following generations show the symptoms of trauma. This can be seen in stories of the children of Holocaust survivors, for example.
Another important field of study is trauma in children. There are children who experience terrible repeat traumas in childhood, but might not fit the rigid definitions of child PTSD, or are poorly diagnosed and don’t receive the help they need.
It matters a lot for those who are trying to get an official diagnosis so they can access the help they need. If, for example, someone needed a PTSD diagnosis to receive government benefits and access to funded therapy, then it can be very disappointing if their trauma is not deemed diagnosable.
If you have the symptoms of trauma but don’t qualify for an official diagnosis of PTSD, do not give up on finding support. Trauma can leave many struggling with work and day-to-day life, which can also affect their finances. Read our article on free or low cost counselling and continue to seek help.
Psychological trauma is treatable, and the right support can mean you finally start to feel yourself again. A good counsellor or psychotherapist works with you to alleviate the symptoms and get to the root of your trauma. If any therapist belittles your sense of being traumatised, or claims that your trauma was not ‘serious enough’, it’s likely time to seek a better therapist.